Architectural Shingles vs 3-Tab Shingles for Lakeland Roofs

Shingles that all look alike from the driveway can be two very different products. The question of architectural shingles vs 3 tab comes down to how the shingle is built: one flat layer, or two or more layers bonded together. That build changes the look, the weight, the wind rating printed on the wrapper, and the warranty that comes with it.

This guide covers how to tell which shingles are on your roof, what the Florida Building Code asks of shingles in wind, why 3-tab shingles are now less common, and how ridge cap shingles finish the top of the roof. For metal, tile and flat roofs as well, see our guide to roofing materials for Lakeland homes. Everything here comes from manufacturer documents, the code text and the published sources linked in each section.

The Main Difference Between Architectural and 3-Tab Shingles

A 3-tab shingle is a single layer of asphalt cut into three tabs, which gives a flat, even pattern. An architectural shingle, also called laminated or dimensional, is made of two or more layers fused together. The extra layer adds thickness, a deeper shadow look and extra weight.

The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association (ARMA) groups shingles by how they are made (ARMA, types of asphalt roofing). It describes strip shingles as about three times as long as they are wide, and says the most common strip shingle is the three-tab. Laminated shingles “contain more than one layer of tabs to create extra thickness,” and ARMA notes they are also called three-dimensional or architectural shingles.

CertainTeed, a shingle maker, describes the two the same way (CertainTeed, types of asphalt roofing shingles):

Feature3-tab (strip) shinglesArchitectural (laminated) shingles
LayersA single layer of asphaltTwo or more layers fused together
LookVery flat, often a slate lookMade to look like wood shake or natural slate
WeightGenerally weigh lessTypically heavier
CostGenerally cost lessCost more (see the cost section below)
WarrantyNot stated by CertainTeedCertainTeed says they have improved warranty protection

The names cause most of the confusion. “Architectural,” “dimensional” and “laminated” all describe the same layered shingle. “Strip” and “3-tab” describe the single-layer kind.

Telling Which Shingles Are on Your Roof

You can usually tell the two apart from the ground. A 3-tab roof shows straight rows of evenly spaced, same-size tabs, like a neat grid. An architectural roof shows uneven, staggered shapes with darker shadow lines, because the bonded layers give each shingle a ragged, thicker edge.

Fixr’s guide to architectural shingles says 3-tab shingles are “designed to offer a uniform, tile-like appearance,” while architectural shingles are thicker and heavier and “feature two or more shingles that are laminated and bonded together” (Fixr, guide to architectural shingles). With that in mind, these signs help:

  • Even grid or random pattern. Straight vertical slots repeating in a regular line point to 3-tab. A patchwork of different widths with no repeating slot points to architectural.
  • Shadow and depth. Architectural shingles show a darker band where the layers overlap. 3-tab shingles look flat.
  • Paperwork. The permit record, the contractor’s invoice or a home inspection report often names the shingle line.
  • Leftover bundles. A spare bundle in the garage usually has the product name and wind class printed on the wrapper.

Look from the yard, a window or with binoculars. Do not climb onto the roof to check. If you need a closer look, a roofing professional can confirm the shingle type during an inspection.

Wind Ratings for Shingles Under the Florida Building Code

The Florida Building Code requires asphalt shingles to be tested and classified for wind under ASTM D3161, ASTM D7158 or TAS 107. A table in the code sets which class is needed for each design wind speed, and the shingle wrapper must be labelled with that class. The rule applies to both shingle types.

Section 1507.2.7.1 of the 2023 Florida Building Code sets the wind rule (Florida Building Code 2023, Chapter 15). Its table runs from a basic wind speed of 110 mph up to 194 mph. At lower speeds the code accepts ASTM D3161 Class D or F, or ASTM D7158 Class D, G or H. At the top of the table it calls for ASTM D7158 Class H and ASTM D3161 Class F.

Other parts of section 1507.2 apply to every asphalt shingle roof:

Code sectionWhat it says
1507.2.1Shingles must be fastened to solidly sheathed decks.
1507.2.2Shingles may be used only on slopes of 2 in 12 or steeper.
1507.2.7At least four fasteners per strip shingle, or two per individual shingle, plus any higher manufacturer minimum.
1507.2.7.1Wind testing and classification under ASTM D3161, ASTM D7158 or TAS 107, with the class on the wrapper.

The code does not say one shingle type is always stronger. What matters is the class on the wrapper of the product used. Fixr lists published wind figures for several architectural lines, such as 110 mph for CertainTeed Landmark and 130 mph for Owens Corning Duration and Oakridge (Fixr, guide to architectural shingles). Those are product figures, so check the data sheet and warranty for the exact shingle on your roof. Your local building department decides which class your address needs.

3-Tab Shingles Are Less Common Today

Manufacturers say 3-tab shingles lost their lead when layered designer shingles arrived. CertainTeed says strip shingles were the main shingle on the market before the 1980s. Today it says they are used mostly by builders of inexpensive homes and by owners replacing a roof that already has strip shingles.

CertainTeed puts it plainly: “Prior to designer shingles being introduced in the 1980s, strip shingles were the predominant roofing shingle in the market” (CertainTeed, types of asphalt roofing shingles). The same page calls dimensional shingles “the most prevalent asphalt shingles.”

ARMA describes the same shift from the industry side. It calls laminated shingles “a favorite among builders, roofing contractors and homebuyers” (ARMA, types of asphalt roofing).

None of this means 3-tab shingles are gone. CertainTeed still describes strip shingles as the lighter, lower-cost choice. For an owner matching an existing 3-tab roof, or working to a tight budget, they remain an option. Fixr’s guide also calls 3-tab shingles “a more cost-effective option” for tight budgets.

Cost, Weight and Lifespan Compared

Architectural shingles cost more, weigh more and are usually sold with longer life claims. Fixr’s guide says they cost almost double 3-tab shingles. CertainTeed says strip shingles are the lightest asphalt shingles. Lifespan figures vary by source and product, so treat any range as a guide, not a promise.

Here is what the sources say:

Point3-tab shinglesArchitectural shinglesSource
PriceLower costAlmost double 3-tabFixr guide
Typical full replacementNot listed$8,000 to $32,000, Fixr’s national market figureFixr roof replacement cost
WeightTypically the lightestTypically heavierCertainTeed categories
Lifespan claims15 to 20 yearsUp to 50 yearsFixr guide

The replacement figure is a national estimate published by Fixr, not a price from this business. Fixr’s roof replacement page also says a standard asphalt shingle roof should last 20 to 30 years. The gap between that range and the “up to 50 years” claim shows why the warranty and the actual product matter more than the label.

Fixr’s guide also lists two downsides of architectural shingles: the higher cost, and the extra non-recyclable material in each shingle. Florida sun, heat and storms all shape real lifespan. Our post on how long a roof lasts in Florida covers those factors.

Ridge Cap Shingles and Why They Matter

Ridge cap shingles are the folded pieces that cover the peak of the roof and the hips where two slopes meet. Owens Corning sells them as a separate product so roofers do not have to cut strip shingles on site. Its data sheet lists a pre-applied sealant bead and a Class F wind classification.

ARMA defines a ridge as “the uppermost, horizontal external angle formed by the intersection of two sloping roof planes,” and a hip as the sloped edge where two roof planes meet (ARMA, frequently asked questions). These lines take the full force of wind from both sides, so the cap pieces on them need to hold well.

The Owens Corning ProEdge Hip and Ridge data sheet lists these features (Owens Corning ProEdge data sheet):

  • Pre-cut pieces. Perforated for easy separation, with “no additional on-site cutting required.”
  • Sealant. A pre-applied continuous sealant bead for quick adhesion.
  • Wind class. Class F (110 mph) wind resistance classification.
  • Fewer pieces. A larger exposure needs fewer pieces than strip shingles to cover the same length.
  • Matching warranty. The cap warranty corresponds with the Owens Corning shingle warranty on the roof.
  • Colour match. Coordinated with the Owens Corning laminate shingle line.

The older habit was to cut 3-tab shingles into ridge pieces. Products like this exist to replace that step. When you get a quote, ask which ridge cap product will be used and whether it is part of the same maker’s system as the field shingles, since warranty terms can depend on it. Ridge vents often sit under the ridge cap as well, which ties into how the attic breathes; see our post on attic ventilation for Lakeland roofs.

Re-Covering an Older Roof Under Florida Code

The Florida Building Code says when a new roof covering may go over an old one and when the old roof must be removed to the deck. Section 1511.3 requires a tear-off where the roof already has two or more coverings, is water soaked or deteriorated, or cannot meet the code’s fastening rules.

Section 1511.3 lists the conditions that require removal down to the deck (Florida Building Code 2023, Chapter 15):

  1. The existing roof is water soaked or has deteriorated so it is not an adequate base.
  2. The existing covering is wood shake, slate, clay, cement or asbestos-cement tile.
  3. The roof has two or more applications of any type of roof covering.
  4. Blisters exist in the roofing, unless they are cut or scraped open and secured first.
  5. The existing covering is used for attachment and the fastening rules of section 1504.1 cannot be met.

Section 1511.1.1 adds a 25 percent rule. Not more than 25 percent of a roof or roof section may be repaired, replaced or recovered in any 12-month period unless the whole roof or section is brought up to code, with an exception for roofs built under the 2007 code or later.

ARMA notes that asphalt shingles “can often be applied directly over existing roofs,” but also that some local rules forbid it over two or more layers, and that the deck must be sound (ARMA, frequently asked questions). This is a summary of the code text, not a ruling on your roof. Your local building department decides how these sections apply, and a licensed roofer handles the permit.

Choosing Shingles for a Lakeland Home

For a Lakeland home, the choice starts with the wind class the code requires for your address, then the product’s data sheet and warranty. Architectural shingles are now the more common choice, while 3-tab shingles cost less and suit matching an existing strip roof. Colour, attic airflow and ridge caps finish the decision.

A short checklist for a quote:

  1. Wind class on the wrapper. Ask which ASTM class the shingle carries and confirm it meets the code table for your address.
  2. Product name and data sheet. Ask for the exact shingle line, not just “architectural.”
  3. Ridge cap product. Ask whether matching hip and ridge shingles from the same maker will be used.
  4. Tear-off or re-cover. Ask whether section 1511.3 requires removal on your roof, and why.
  5. Warranty terms. Ask for the written warranty and what installation details it depends on.

Shingle colour also affects heat on the roof; our post on shingle roof colors in the Florida sun covers that choice. When you are ready to compare options for your own home, the Roof Repair Lakeland FL page on roof replacement in Lakeland explains what a replacement involves.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the downsides of architectural shingles?

Fixr’s guide names two: architectural shingles cost almost double 3-tab shingles, and they use extra non-recyclable material (Fixr, guide to architectural shingles). CertainTeed also notes they are typically heavier than strip shingles (CertainTeed), so ask a roofer whether weight matters for your roof.

Does anyone use 3-tab shingles anymore?

Yes, though less than before. CertainTeed says strip shingles led the market before the 1980s and are now used mostly by builders of inexpensive homes and by owners re-roofing homes that already have strip shingles (CertainTeed, types of asphalt roofing shingles).

How do I tell if I have 3-tab or architectural shingles?

From the ground, 3-tab shingles show a flat, even grid of same-size tabs, while architectural shingles look thicker and uneven with darker shadow lines, as Fixr describes (Fixr guide). Permit records, invoices or a spare bundle’s wrapper can confirm it. Do not climb on the roof to check.

Can I put architectural shingles over 3-tab shingles?

The Florida Building Code, section 1511.3, requires removal to the deck if the roof already has two or more coverings, is water soaked or deteriorated, has unsecured blisters, or cannot meet the fastening rules (Florida Building Code 2023, Chapter 15). Your local building department and a licensed roofer decide whether a re-cover is allowed on your roof.

Are architectural shingles really better than 3-tab?

They are thicker, heavier and, per CertainTeed, carry improved warranty protection (CertainTeed). For wind, the Florida Building Code judges any shingle by its tested class on the wrapper, not by type (Florida Building Code 2023, Chapter 15), so compare the actual products.

What shingles do most roofers use?

CertainTeed calls dimensional, or architectural, shingles “the most prevalent asphalt shingles” (CertainTeed), and ARMA calls laminated shingles a favorite among builders, roofing contractors and homebuyers (ARMA). Neither source gives a percentage.